What if We've Been Doing it Wrong?
Reclaiming Evangelism
There is a quiet crisis unfolding in the American church, and most of us feel it even if we cannot name it. According to Lifeway Research, the average churchgoer shares their faith twice in a six-month period. Twice. The Barna Group has found that a majority of Christians believe other faiths can approach God through their own religious paths. And perhaps most telling of all, 56 percent of Christians surveyed by the Billy Graham Evangelistic Institute believe their faith is a strictly private matter.
The result? A deep, pervasive awkwardness around the subject of evangelism. A sense that sharing our faith is somehow an imposition. A creeping suspicion that maybe it is not really our job.
But what if the problem is not that we are doing evangelism too much? What if the problem is that we have fundamentally misunderstood what evangelism actually is?
What Evangelism Is Not
Before we can reclaim something, we have to be honest about what went wrong. And there are three common misconceptions worth naming directly.
First, evangelism is not easy. The church has spent decades trying to package faith-sharing into simple, repeatable steps, and the intention behind that effort is good. But somewhere along the way, we began marketing the gospel itself as something easy to accept. Dietrich Bonhoeffer had a name for a gospel stripped of its cost: cheap grace. The New Testament is clear that belief is the doorway to salvation, but genuine faith is never passive. As James makes plain, faith without works is dead. A gospel presentation that invites people to add Jesus to their existing lives without calling them to transformation is not the whole gospel. It is a fragment of it.
Second, evangelism is not an event. Door-knocking campaigns, revival services, vacation Bible school, summer camps, crusades -- these things can be meaningful touch points. They can bring people into proximity with the gospel. But when we treat evangelism as something that happens at scheduled intervals, we give ourselves permission to neglect it the rest of the time. If it is an event, it can be compartmentalized. And compartmentalized evangelism is not what Jesus modeled.
Third, evangelism is not simply education. Knowing Scripture is vital. Theological grounding matters. But we are not trying to transfer a set of doctrines into someone's head. We are introducing people to a person -- the living Jesus Christ -- who desires a real relationship with them. When we reduce discipleship to information transfer, we end up with churches that are, as one observer put it, educated far beyond their ability to obey.
What Evangelism Actually Is
Here is the reframe that changes everything: evangelism is engagement in the life of Jesus.
It is not a program you run. It is a rhythm you adopt. It is the way Jesus himself brought people close -- cutting through peripheral arguments, asking the right questions, and patiently walking people from curiosity all the way to commitment.
And the goal, as the Reformers understood it, is not simply conversion. It is union with Christ. Jesus himself prays for this in John 17, that his followers would be one with him as he is one with the Father. Paul echoes the same vision in Ephesians 4, describing the saints growing up into the full stature and measure of Christ. That is what we are after. Not a raised hand. Not a name on a membership roll. Union with Jesus.
Four Invitations
When you trace the way Jesus made disciples through the Gospels, a pattern emerges. It is not a program. It is a sequence of invitations, each one building on the last.
The first is an invitation to investigate. In John 1, two disciples of John the Baptist begin following Jesus out of curiosity. Jesus turns and asks them what they are seeking. When they ask where he is staying, his answer is simple and profound: "Come and see." He does not hand them a pamphlet. He opens the door and invites them in. This is where evangelism begins -- not with a presentation, but with proximity. People need to see the Christian life lived before they can understand what they are being asked to embrace. That means giving people a seat at your table. Letting them into your home and your rhythms. Letting them see your warts alongside your faith, because then they will also see grace.
The second is an invitation to follow, or more precisely, an invitation to leave. In Matthew 4, Jesus finds Peter and Andrew on the Sea of Galilee and calls them to leave their nets. Later, he walks up to Matthew -- a tax collector, a man enriched by exploitation and despised by his community -- and simply says, "Follow me." Both invitations require the same thing: leaving the old life behind. There must come a point where someone who has been investigating is invited to take a step. Not pressured. Not manipulated. But genuinely called to move.
The third is an invitation to become. In Matthew 16, Jesus tells his disciples plainly that following him means denying themselves, taking up a cross, and losing their lives in order to find them. This is the cost of discipleship, and it is the part of the gospel we are most tempted to leave out. But withholding it is not kindness. It is dishonesty. The invitation to become is not primarily about what we give up. It is about who we are called to be.
The fourth is an invitation to go and do. The Great Commission in Matthew 28 is not just a call to foreign missions. It is a call to look at the people already in your orbit -- your neighbors, your coworkers, your classmates -- and recognize that God has placed you there on purpose.
The Long Game
This process cannot be rushed. It cannot be mass-produced. It is, by its very nature, slow, relational, and costly. It requires patience, vulnerability, and a willingness to play the long game with people.
The only question left to answer is a simple one: who needs a seat at your table?
There is a quiet crisis unfolding in the American church, and most of us feel it even if we cannot name it. According to Lifeway Research, the average churchgoer shares their faith twice in a six-month period. Twice. The Barna Group has found that a majority of Christians believe other faiths can approach God through their own religious paths. And perhaps most telling of all, 56 percent of Christians surveyed by the Billy Graham Evangelistic Institute believe their faith is a strictly private matter.
The result? A deep, pervasive awkwardness around the subject of evangelism. A sense that sharing our faith is somehow an imposition. A creeping suspicion that maybe it is not really our job.
But what if the problem is not that we are doing evangelism too much? What if the problem is that we have fundamentally misunderstood what evangelism actually is?
What Evangelism Is Not
Before we can reclaim something, we have to be honest about what went wrong. And there are three common misconceptions worth naming directly.
First, evangelism is not easy. The church has spent decades trying to package faith-sharing into simple, repeatable steps, and the intention behind that effort is good. But somewhere along the way, we began marketing the gospel itself as something easy to accept. Dietrich Bonhoeffer had a name for a gospel stripped of its cost: cheap grace. The New Testament is clear that belief is the doorway to salvation, but genuine faith is never passive. As James makes plain, faith without works is dead. A gospel presentation that invites people to add Jesus to their existing lives without calling them to transformation is not the whole gospel. It is a fragment of it.
Second, evangelism is not an event. Door-knocking campaigns, revival services, vacation Bible school, summer camps, crusades -- these things can be meaningful touch points. They can bring people into proximity with the gospel. But when we treat evangelism as something that happens at scheduled intervals, we give ourselves permission to neglect it the rest of the time. If it is an event, it can be compartmentalized. And compartmentalized evangelism is not what Jesus modeled.
Third, evangelism is not simply education. Knowing Scripture is vital. Theological grounding matters. But we are not trying to transfer a set of doctrines into someone's head. We are introducing people to a person -- the living Jesus Christ -- who desires a real relationship with them. When we reduce discipleship to information transfer, we end up with churches that are, as one observer put it, educated far beyond their ability to obey.
What Evangelism Actually Is
Here is the reframe that changes everything: evangelism is engagement in the life of Jesus.
It is not a program you run. It is a rhythm you adopt. It is the way Jesus himself brought people close -- cutting through peripheral arguments, asking the right questions, and patiently walking people from curiosity all the way to commitment.
And the goal, as the Reformers understood it, is not simply conversion. It is union with Christ. Jesus himself prays for this in John 17, that his followers would be one with him as he is one with the Father. Paul echoes the same vision in Ephesians 4, describing the saints growing up into the full stature and measure of Christ. That is what we are after. Not a raised hand. Not a name on a membership roll. Union with Jesus.
Four Invitations
When you trace the way Jesus made disciples through the Gospels, a pattern emerges. It is not a program. It is a sequence of invitations, each one building on the last.
The first is an invitation to investigate. In John 1, two disciples of John the Baptist begin following Jesus out of curiosity. Jesus turns and asks them what they are seeking. When they ask where he is staying, his answer is simple and profound: "Come and see." He does not hand them a pamphlet. He opens the door and invites them in. This is where evangelism begins -- not with a presentation, but with proximity. People need to see the Christian life lived before they can understand what they are being asked to embrace. That means giving people a seat at your table. Letting them into your home and your rhythms. Letting them see your warts alongside your faith, because then they will also see grace.
The second is an invitation to follow, or more precisely, an invitation to leave. In Matthew 4, Jesus finds Peter and Andrew on the Sea of Galilee and calls them to leave their nets. Later, he walks up to Matthew -- a tax collector, a man enriched by exploitation and despised by his community -- and simply says, "Follow me." Both invitations require the same thing: leaving the old life behind. There must come a point where someone who has been investigating is invited to take a step. Not pressured. Not manipulated. But genuinely called to move.
The third is an invitation to become. In Matthew 16, Jesus tells his disciples plainly that following him means denying themselves, taking up a cross, and losing their lives in order to find them. This is the cost of discipleship, and it is the part of the gospel we are most tempted to leave out. But withholding it is not kindness. It is dishonesty. The invitation to become is not primarily about what we give up. It is about who we are called to be.
The fourth is an invitation to go and do. The Great Commission in Matthew 28 is not just a call to foreign missions. It is a call to look at the people already in your orbit -- your neighbors, your coworkers, your classmates -- and recognize that God has placed you there on purpose.
The Long Game
This process cannot be rushed. It cannot be mass-produced. It is, by its very nature, slow, relational, and costly. It requires patience, vulnerability, and a willingness to play the long game with people.
The only question left to answer is a simple one: who needs a seat at your table?
Posted in The Church Defined
Posted in #Evangelism, #Gospel, #Discipleship, #MissionCreep, #GreatCommission, #UnionWithChrist, #Faith, #Salvation, #JesusChrist, #ComeAndSee
Posted in #Evangelism, #Gospel, #Discipleship, #MissionCreep, #GreatCommission, #UnionWithChrist, #Faith, #Salvation, #JesusChrist, #ComeAndSee
Recent
Archive
2026
January
March
May
June
July
August
September
October
2025
April
May
June
July
August
September
November

No Comments